Description of included studies using the PICO framework
Author | Study | Intervention | Outcomes | Results | Other | |||
First author year location | Design (assessments) duration | Description | N Age | Programme description | Psychosocial | Visits/costs | Missing data | Funding Conflict of interest |
1. Referral, 2. link worker, 3. providers | ||||||||
Elston 2019 England, UK40 | Before–after (two times) 12 months | 50+ with 2+ chronic conditions | n=151 assessed n=126 completed | ‘Local health, social and economic services’. p. 2 |
| Health and social care use | 40/126 people 12 months (32%) | Torbay Medical Research Fund Torbay and South Devon NHS Foundation Trust |
73% women | 79.6 y (mean) |
| ||||||
Giebel 2021 England, UK41 | Before–after (three times) 6 months | People with dementia diagnosis and family carer | n=25, 14 people with dementia | ‘”Happy and Healthy” classes, which comprise physical and mental well-being exercises’. p. 1854 1. Psychiatrist, GPs and self-referral. 2. NR. 3. Community centre advisers. | SWEMWBS | NA | 3/25 people 3 months (12%) | National Institute for Health Research Applied Research Collaboration North West Coast |
36% women | 74 (8) y Mean (SD) | 10/25 people 6 months (40%) | ||||||
Jones 2020 Wales, UK42 | Before–after (two times) 16 weeks | Age 55+ years; community dwelling; no or mild cognitive impairment; and families | n=159 | Health Precinct ‘Lifestyle Management, National Exercise Referral Scheme (NERS) and Cardiac Rehabilitation’. p. 2 |
| GP appointments | 93/159 people did not complete study (58%). | Health and Care Research Wales Grant |
61% women | 72.4 (8.3) y Mean (SD) |
| ||||||
Kim 2021 South Korea43 | Before–after (two times) 10 weeks | Age 65+ years from rural area | n=16 | ‘The interventions consisted of three parts: music storytelling, a self-help group, and gardening’. p. 2 |
| NA | 6/16 people did not complete programme (38%). | National Research Foundation of Korea, Grant/Award |
All women | 82 (5.9) y Mean (SD) |
| ||||||
Loftus 2017 Northern Ireland, UK44 | Quality Improvement (two times) 12 weeks before and 12 weeks during the programme | 65+ and chronic condition, GP visits+ or multiple meds | n=68 | ‘Social clubs, Men’s Shed, counselling, arts programme, falls prevention, exercises classes, crochet classes, personal development, craft classes, befriending and computer courses’. p. 97 | NA | GP surgery visits GP home visits GP telephone calls Repeat medication prescriptions | 40/68 (59%) declined social prescribing activity (not in per protocol analysis) | |
71% women | 72.9 (7.3) y Mean (SD) |
| ||||||
Thomson 2018 England, UK45 | Before–after (three times) 10 weeks | 65–94 y at risk for social isolation or loneliness | n=115 | Museum-based programme | MWM-OA | NR | Grant from the Arts and Humanities Research Council | |
63% women | 65–94 y |
| ||||||
Vogelpoel 2014 London, UK46 | Before–after (2 weeks) 12 weeks | 61–95 y with sensory impairment, socially isolated | n=12 | Community arts programme | WEMWBS | 4/12 people did not attend the full programme (33%) | Authors work at Sense, a national charity for people with sensory impairment | |
75% women | Mean >80 y |
|
Please note we did not include physical outcomes in the table as there were so few reported in the included studies.
EQ-5D-5L, EuroQol-5 Dimensions-5 Levels; GDS-K, Geriatric Depression Scale Korean Version; GP, general practitioner; MUM-OA, Museum Wellbeing Measure for Older Adults; NA, not assessed; NR, not reported; PAM, patient activation measure; PICO, population, intervention, comparator and outcome; RCFS, Rockwood Clinical Frail Scale; SWEMWBS, Short Warwick-Edinburgh Mental Well-being Scale; WEMWBS, Warwick-Edinburgh Mental Health and Well-being Scale; WHOQOL-BREF, WHO Quality of Life (Shorter version); y, years.